Superimposed volt/current graphs - 9x5 3-blade in red and 11x4.7 2-blade in blue
Further to my informal testing of 3S and 4S batteries with the same prop I did a test with 9x5 3-blade props (http://www.hobbyking.com/hobbyking/store/uh_viewItem.asp?idProduct=...) and 11x4.7 2-blade props (APC SF 11x4.7).
Test procedure: using freshly charged batteries I took off and hovered at ~2m for 60 secs and then landed.
Quad specs:
APM2
KDA20-22L motors from Hobbyking
2 x Super Simple 25-30A ESC's from Hobbyking
2 x Hexfet 25A ESC's from Hobbyking (2 of 4 were DOA)
3S 3000mAh Turnigy 25C
X525 frame
Average values:
| 9x5 | |
Va - 11.75V, Pa - 161.6W, Aa - 13.8A 11x4.7 Va - 11.89V, Pa - 150.2W, Aa - 12.7A |
11x4.7 uses ~11W less power and ~1.1A less current on average for the 60 second flight than the 9x5
Full graphs below: 9x5 first.
Comment by Jonathan M on March 7, 2012 at 2:04pm Cool! I have done similar with my eagletree. What's the weight of your quad. You may be interested in this data.. CP and CT curves for the APC 11x4.7 SF from a windtunnel http://www.ae.illinois.edu/m-selig/props/propDB.html. I have been meaning to do more testing, but my thrust stand needs fixing and so does the v2.4.1 firmware :)

Quad weighs 1.3kg, flying v2.5 Alpha, what is CP and CT on those graphs?
Comment by Jonathan M on March 7, 2012 at 11:04pm 1.3kg Nice! right around my weight, I will have to do some more flights with my eagletree for comparison. I am also flying 11x4.7 props.
CT and CP are non-dimensional coefficiecnts for thrust and power (similiar to CL and CD). It's generally how you gauge the performance of props. http://www.mh-aerotools.de/airfoils/propuls3.htm is a better explanation
Did you grab v2.5alpha from GIT or is there a zip floating around?

Graham, i've same triblade props but i tried and have poor trust, i use now 10x4.5 EPP on my X525.

The 3 blade props have been fine for me (once balanced) but have had two in-flight breakages with 10x4.5's from GoodLuckBuy so advise to avoid those at all costs. The APC SF props are good as are the E-flite SF props.

Nice, i use 10x4.5 Mikrokopter EPP or GAUI.
Comment
Season Two of the Trust Time Trial (T3) Contest has now begun. The fourth round is an accuracy round for multicopters, which requires contestants to fly a cube. The deadline is April 14th.54 members
203 members
88 members
24 members
720 members
© 2013 Created by Chris Anderson.
Powered by

You need to be a member of DIY Drones to add comments!
Join DIY Drones