Large frame Quadcopter motor options

Hello everyone,I know that large, heavy lift quadcopter might be a nitch in this community but I see that there are several here building these.From all that I have read and experienced when building them with low kv, large motors there are some problems to overcome. I have personally used the U8 Tiger Motor 170kv. The problems I have observed are the following.High vibrationMotor/ESC stallsInstability in loiter, Position holdI have been looking at the KDE7208XF-135. I am wondering if there are any others using them that can offer any positive comments or findings using them.If not the KDE motors what other options are there for this application.ThanksWill

You need to be a member of diydrones to add comments!

Join diydrones

Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • Hello,

    yes your High Vibration cause by your frame! It's not stiff enough your arms are flexing too much.

    to fix you need larger tubes 30mm + or 30mm + rectangular or square tube carbon fiber large motor mount clamps to go with. 

    what you mean motor ESC stall? what type of ESC are you using?

    • I use castle creation 50A esc's. I have yet to pull the log information from the esc's. Right before the quad flipped I heard a distinct sound of signal sync stall. T u is I a sound I've heard on YouTube when people tested different esc's with the U8 T-motors.

      The sound was not as dramatic as thus in the video but you get the ideahttps://m.youtube.com/watch?v=aDxUda1SvSQ.

      Will
      • Hello,

        My be choice of ESC are not the best Castle ESC has had lots of issues please search on the forum you will see.  Over kill known to work well Hobbywing Platinum 100A PRO ESC 2-12 cells lithium battery

        but new cheaper X rotor 50Amp ESC better bet.

        http://brushlessgimbal.ca/Multi-Rotor-Products-Parts/ESC/Hobbywing-...

        your my want look at arms upgrades for stiffer frame 600mm available.

        http://brushlessgimbal.ca/Cinestar-Parts/Carbon-Octagonal-Square-Bo...

        Hobbywing Xrotor 50A Speed Controller for Multicopter [XRotor-50A] - $35.00 : www.brushlessgimbal.c…
        www.brushlessgimbal.ca Hobbywing Xrotor 50A Speed Controller for Multicopter [XRotor-50A] - Features 1.1 rotor is special program, the throttle respo…
  • Hi Will,

    i dont think that you could pick much better motors than the U8. The vibrations you experienced are very likely caused by insufficient balancing of the props. Or you bought used motors that have been crashed and have a bended shaft therefore... I use these foxtech motors:

    http://www.foxtechfpv.com/foxtech-motor-s4016-kv380-v2-p-1599.html

    They were on sale for 35usd per piece. They are balanced quite well and have a good thrust / efficience balance.

    Best regards

    Seb

This reply was deleted.

Activity