The CanberraUAV Outback Challenge team has put together a package that will allow anyone to try the image recognition system we developed for our successful 2012 OBC entry. We hope that by releasing this in an easier to use form that other OBC teams and anyone interested in image recognition in UAVs will be able to reproduce what we've done and build upon it for their own systems.
The fundamental problem that our system is meant to solve is providing real-time recognition of objects on the ground from a UAV, while requiring only a low bandwidth radio link between the aircraft and the ground station. A lot of UAVs are run using analog video links from the plane to the ground, but we think that is not a good way to do many search and rescue and environmental tasks. The problems with an analog video link are:
- the quality of the video is often greatly degraded by being sent over the analog link, making it hard to spot small objects
- the task of an operator staring at a video screen for hours is much too hard. The operator may notice something flash by, then has to decide whether to rewind (possibly missing something else in the search) or to skip the object
- in many (most?) parts of the world analog video links may violate local radio licensing regulations
We think the solution is for the aircraft to do an initial pass of image recognition to find "interesting" objects on the ground, and then to show small (low bandwidth) thumbnails of those objects on the ground station, overlaid on a satellite map of the area. The operator can then select which of these thumbnails to look at more closely, bringing down a full high resolution image around that object from the plane over the telemetry link when needed. When using this method the operator gets a complete overview of the search area, and can quickly focus on areas of interest, using the human to decide which of the objects that the computer shows up are worth investigating. That was the strategy we successfully used in our 2012 OBC flight.
Up to now the image recognition code we developed for that competition was fairly deeply embedded in the MAVProxy module we used, making it hard for other teams or UAV researchers to run the algorithm over their own data to see how it performs. So to address that we have now put together a set of packages that can be installed on Linux, Windows or MacOS to try the system for yourself.
The new tool is called geosearch.py, and is a standalone UAV search tool that operates offline on a set of images, using either EXIF positioning data in the images, or a MAVLink telemetry log for geo-referencing. It runs the same code that we use in our real-time system embedded in the aircraft, but converted to run as a local GUI tool on a desktop computer. Note that the algorithms we use are tuned for speed. They are not state of the art computer vision algorithms, but they are fast, allowing them to run in real-time on a low power ARM Linux box embedded in an aircraft. We originally tried to use algorithms from the excellent OpenCV system, but found them too slow for our application. We do however use some OpenCV helper functions in our code to make the system a bit simpler.
Release of data from our OBC flight
As a companion to this tool we have released the images captured from our OBC 2012 flight for anyone to download, along with the telemetry logs and other files needed to reproduce the result. The images are kindly hosted by CSIRO in Australia, and are available from the CSIRO Outback Challenge website.
On that site you will find a set of 20 zip files containing the raw images from our flight. If you download and extract those zip files you will end up with a directory called 'raw' which contains 17042 pgm image files. Those files are 8 bit raw Bayer grid files of 1280x960, which are the raw images from our PtGrey Chameleon camera. We're hoping those files will be useful to anyone wanting a decent sized set of UAV images for research, or for training an algorithm for the next Outback Challenge.
(NOTE: as of the time of writing the CSIRO site has the images as 17k separate image files, those should be converted to the 20 zip files for easier download soon).
We also provide a tool called pgm_convert.py which will take those pgm raw images and convert them to other formats, most commonly to lossless PNG files.
How to try our system for yourself
If you watch the video and want to try our system on your own data, or on the data from our OBC flight, then you will need to install a set of python packages that provide the basic system tools we use in our code.
On Windows you need Python 2.7, plus a set of extra python packages. To make life easier for windows users we have collected all of the packages you need in this directory. Note that this includes both the packages needed to run our tools, and the packages needed to build our tools for yourself for when you want to modify the code.On Linux installing the basic python tools is a bit easier. For example, on an Ubuntu Linux system the following command should be enough:
sudo apt-get install python-wxgtk2.8 python-matplotlib python-numpy python-pyexiv2 python-opencv python-httplib2 libjpeg-turbo-progs
If you are using MacOS, then you should install a suitable Python 2.7 package first, then use easy_install to add the required additional packages.
Once you have the basic tools installed, the next step is to install the 3 CanberraUAV python packages, pymavlink, MAVProxy and cuav. You can get those packages from the python packaging index:
- https://pypi.python.org/pypi/pymavlink
- https://pypi.python.org/pypi/MAVProxy
- https://pypi.python.org/pypi/cuav
That will allow you to download tar balls or windows installers for each package. If you are going to modify the code, then you will be better off downloading the source from our github repository.
To build the packages yourself (instead of using the pre-built packages), you would use the following commands in each of the 3 package directories. For Linux or MacOS, use this:
python setup.py build install --user
for Windows use this:
python setup.py build -c mingw32 install
Note that for building on WIndows you also need to install the MinGW package.
How it all works
To see how it all works, you can either read the code (just follow the above links to our code repository) or you can watch a presentation I gave in January 2012 which explains the algorithm to some extent (video and slides).
We'd also encourage you to ask questions on the CanberraUAV mailing list, or on the Outback Challenge discussion group.
How much bandwidth does it use?
The aim of this system is to allow for real-time UAV search with only a low bandwidth telemetry link to the aircraft. It is possible to run the system with a 64 kbit/s ISM band radio, such as the excellent RFD900 radio.
To make this possible we developed a new network transport protocol called block_xmit (mp4-video, ogg-video, slides, implementation), which allows us to intermix low bandwidth thumbnail images and python objects with normal MAVLink telemetry over a single radio link. The system also scales up to higher bandwidth links, so if you happen to have a high bandwidth ethernet bridge (such as a Ubiquity Bullet) in your aircraft, and you are close enough to the ground station to have a good link, then the system will transmit real-time images that gives the effect of a digital video link. That capability can be seen in the demonstration video above.
The block_xmit protocol also prioritizes images based on the image score from the recognition algorithm, so you can set quite a low threshold for what images to send, and if a high scoring object (such as Joe!) turns up it will jump the queue in the radio link and be shown to the operator quickly.
For our aircraft we combine both types of radio link, with the results of our imaging system coming over both a 5.8GHz Ubiquity ethernet bridge and a 900MHz RFD900 telemetry radio (with smaller thumbnail sizes to save bandwidth). That gives us redundancy in case a particular radio technology does not perform well on the day.
Geo-referencing
Included in the system is a geo-referencing system that uses the MAVLink telemetry stream along with image timestamps to work out the geographic location (latitude/longitude) of any region of interest in the image. These are displayed on the map in various formats (degrees decimal, degrees/minutes/seconds and UTM grid coordinates).
If you instead have a camera with a built-in GPS that tags images with EXIF geo-referencing tags the the code can instead use those for geo-referencing. That tends to result in much less accuracy however, as the EXIF tags don't contain nearly as much information about the aircraft attitude, which makes a big difference.
Also note that our current system uses local timestamps in the raw pgm filenames to work match the time to the MAVLink log. That is a mistake which we will fix in a future release. It means that if you are using our OBC data in a timezone other than Queensland you need to use the time offset option in the geosearch.py program to adjust the time to match the times in the MAVLink log. For example, if you are perth, which is 2 hours west of Queensland, then you would use an offset of -7200 seconds.
Next Steps
Some parts of our algorithm were tuned for the expected object sizes of the OBC competition (about 2 meters by 0.5 meters) and for the altitude and images sizes we used. We'd like to parametrize those aspects of the code to make it easier to use for a wider variety of tasks and camera systems.
We'd also like to make it easier to plug in different scoring filters. The recognition algorithm works in two stages, a first stage that finds anything unusual in the image, then a second stage that converts that region to HSV colour space and applies some simple heuristics to score the region. We'd like users to be able to easily plugin different scoring systems to suit their own image search task, as not everyone is looking for a lost hiker wearing blue jeans and a yellow shirt!
We are also interested in adapting our system to thermal cameras, such as the Tamarisk 640, and we hope to do some testing with that system later this year.
Please share your improvements
If you use this code in your own system then please share your improvements! You can clone our repository on github, or post an issue, or just discuss your changes on our mailing list. If we work together we can create a system which will end up saving lives, so please don't just keep your improvements to yourself.
Comments
Well, I guess more traditional methods are more subject to all kinds of noise in your image.
Hi Dries,
The LCA2012 talk I link to gives a bit more detail, but basically its a colour histogram method, with locality for physical region, and some HSV filtering heuristics at the end. It's not a traditional computer vision algorithm (or at least it doesn't match any I'm aware of).
The mission was planned with terrain following, so the plane was always at 90m AGL. The terrain following used both GeoScience Australia data and SRTM (the GA data didn't cover the whole mission area).
Cheers, Tridge
Hi Tridge.. great post and thanks for sharing your code!
In the recognition part, do you first apply a high pass filter, and what would be the size of the kernel?
Once you have found Jo, what was the accuracy of the direct georeferencing? Did you use a local digital elevation model to do this or something like a SRTM DEM?
It's also nice that the compactness filter finds the cows on the way home. APM as a livestock counter :-)
I've now added a "filter type" option to geosearch that allows you to enable the better object filtering that we were using on Matt Ridleys ground station for OBC 2012. It produces much better results. Here is the result of a search with minscore=50 with the "compactness" filter enabled and thumbnails sorted by score (the scores are reduced using compactness). As you can see, Joe really shows up well with compactness enabled.
Have got it to work under windows 7 but not under windows xp ,this is what I get in windows xp.
@John,I just tried it on a RaspberryPi and I found that I had to disable the Neon vector optimization for it to run.
I've put some benchmark results comparing the RaspberryPi to a Odroid-X2 and a Linux laptop here:
https://github.com/tridge/cuav/tree/master/tests/benchmarks
It shows that each core on the 4-core Odroid-X2 is more than 6x faster than the RaspberryPi for the critical 'scan' operation. The cuav MAVProxy module runs the scans in parallel across multiple images, so it can use all 4 cores, which means it will get well over 20x the scan rate of the RPi (as it is primarily CPU bound, not memory bandwidth bound).
So if you are looking for a small board to run this on then the RPi would work, but only at low frame rates and low resolution. Try the Odroid-U2 for a much faster board with a similar size to the RPi.
Cheers, Tridge
Must be a lot of work testing every change on every operating system, even though you only use Linux in flight.
Genial!
Good job Tridgel...
@John, yes, it will run on a RaspberryPi. The Pi isn't very fast, so the frame rate it will handle in real time won't be high, but it should work fine for say 2 frames per second with a 1280x960 camera for example.That's just a guess though. Run the tests/cuav_benchmark.py benchmark on your RPi to get an idea of the speed. Use any of the test images from the CanberraUAV data set as input to the benchmark.
It would be really interesting to combine this code with the new RPi board camera and see how it does. That could make for a very light and simple UAV search system. If the RPi isn't fast enough for the frame rate you want then you could use a Odroid-U2, which is just as small and much faster.
Cheers, Tridge