I had a crash a while back from high alt in auto mode, it flipped and was tumbling, and looked like one prop was stopped/freewheeling. I put it into stablize on the way down but it never recovered. That was just after starting out though, so I just wrote it off as some unknown teething trouble and moved on.

Second flip crash last week when I was doing maximum lift testing with my quad, it flipped from two meters, I figured I'd gone too far with the weight and tripped the self-presevation logic in one of the ESCs. They all seemed to work afterward, but one had a slight burning smell so I replaced it. I'm not too worried about that crash though, as I was pushing it.

 

But today's crash has really shaken my confidence, I was flying around a little aggressively as I wanted to log the current draw during these types of maneuvers, but at the time it flipped it wasn't working very hard at all. One motor just seemed to stop and it tumbled from an alt of a few meters, breaking an arm.

I've attached logs from today's crash (with current and motor logging). I had a look through, max current draw was a couple of spikes up to 53 and 55 amps, but mostly much lower, and low right before the moment of death. All motors/ESCs functioned after the crash, and nothing was even warm let alone hot.

Any advice would be much appreciated, the only thing I'm thinking of is replacing all of my ESCs with higher load+quality ones. Currently I'm using the stock 20amp ones that come with the 3DR Quad C kit, though #4 was replaced with a jrdrones replacement after the second crash last week, it looks the same though. I'm spinning 11x4.7 APC props on 880 kv motors.

 

BTW, is there any way of having the current logged more frequently? Seems incredibly sparse by default.

2013-02-09 10-44 5 - crash.kmz

2013-02-09 10-44 5.log

2013-02-09 10-44 5.log.gpx

You need to be a member of diydrones to add comments!

Join diydrones

Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • Check the ESC on the motor you suspect is cutting off, either A: its bad, or B: configured incorrectly possibly or C: is malfunctioning and could just be defective. Also did you individually properly calibrated each ESC when you built this craft? I have seen where one ESC is catching up to the others, it lags a few miliseconds behind, due to in proper ESC calibration, thus when in aggressive flight or heavy lift it is lagging behind and when you throttle down it cuts off first before the others. I have seen many APM quads setup wrong like this and it is a recipe for flippage! Just a thought....

  • A quick log browse at the motor drives shows something was awry...

    3692617425?profile=original

    The red motor is the first in the column (as I graphed it). There are the drive commands to the individual ESCs. The yellow lines show a significant reversal of a drive as compared to the others. The two sections where the drives went way up and then suddenly reversed, twice, is odd.

    What TX and RX are you using on this aircraft?

    -=Doug

  • Before I browse your logs, why not tether or secure the aircraft and run it dry?

    This would give a log in a controlled situation and also possibly help save a few props and other damage?

    How many flights/battery-run-downs have you gotten between crashes?

    -=Doug

This reply was deleted.

Activity