Discussions

Best flight times, electric vs nitro...etc.(plane)?

Posted by Ben Weber on June 14, 2013 at 8:51pm

Hi, 

I would like to get into flying drones and i'm really excited I just don't know what to buy. Since I would like to have a FPV system and of course Ardupilot.  I'm about to purchase the already made system from Udrone but I was really hoping for some longer flight times than the standard 30-40 minutes.  How about 3+ hours? 

Is Nitro out of the question or really that much harder to use with Ardupilot? I'm thinking generally I could get better flight times.  I guess you could say i'm a stereotypical redneck engineer that lives in North Dakota in the middle of the oil boom so I don't think oil/loud engines is necessarily a problem for me..

I have read a lot of people saying they are getting longer flight times but reading on later in the post it becomes more and more apparent that they are making up stories so I would appreciate an honest opinion.

I am leaning towards an already made kit but I wouldn't mind just a plane with an FPV system to calibrate/practice with before I start using APM. Eventually I would like to add some thermal imaging/image tracking to the live video stream which I might not be able to accomplish but it sure would be fun to try and I will of course post updates about my progress.

With these future goals in mind where should I start?  What airframe/model will have a high payload capacity and 3+ hour flight time?

I know all of you veteran APM guys are busy and maybe this seems like a silly post to answer I would appreciate any help/guidance/direction/patience I can get.

You need to be a member of diydrones to add comments!

Join diydrones

Email me when people reply –
Follow

Replies

  • Duffy January 30, 2016 at 11:14am

    Hi There,

     We have got more than 4 hours on the Raptor E1 using a 26,000mah 6 S lipo and custom made large diameter propellers on a slow spinning motor.

     Best

  • Anton Rada January 24, 2014 at 3:03am

    Hi,   I have been reading about the question of using a nitro engine in an X8 in an attempt to get better flight times.    

    I started down this path about a year ago,     Here is the bad video of an X8 fitted with a 19cc glow engine:  

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LIhw64x5ous

     

    I had flown the X8 electric  very successfully with flight times over an hour,  and it flew well.      I decided to try a 4 stroke  nitro engine  and made a new aluminum chaise to mount the engine and wings to.      It flew OK, but not as easily as the electric.    I needed to keep the speed up, as I think the drag was slightly to high.      The ASP engine did not seem to have excessive power for the job.

    I originally wanted to mount the engine as a pusher,  however I had trouble with getting a pusher prop,  so the engine went to the front.     Then the next problem is launching it, and landing it without prop damage;   so I put fixed landing gear on it.      This added to the drag,  but was necessary as I have farm paddocks for an airstrip.       I did try, a catapult launch with the glow engine.    This was tricky to master as the engine got starved of fuel on launch.    the trick was non return valves. 

     

    I have since abandoned the X8 Glow and made a scratch built a traditional tail plane with glow engine,  which flew for the first time yesterday:

     

    First was a glide test:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GcohDM7yT2Y&feature=youtu.be

    Then a powered maiden flight:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PTPFYZ-nwH8&feature=youtu.be

     

    it has 2.6m wingspan  and 30cc APS 4 stroke glow engine.     has plenty of power,  and I estimate fuel consumption to be about 500 ml per hour.     It has plenty of payload so I think it could get endurance of a few hours if required.

    It is a fully made up design, and built out of carbon fibre , blue foam and aluminum.     wing design is made up , but is a mix of CUB and Telimaster,  with 3deg dihedral, and some winglets from an old funjet...!

    These planes can take up a lot of time, but it is very rewarding to see them fly after so many hours in the workshop...!!! 

     

     

     

     

  • Michael Leasure December 23, 2013 at 7:06am
    I am flying an X8 with 5800mah, 3 cell lipo and easily getting 1 hour flights will full autopilot and FPV gear. The complete weight, as flown, is 5 pounds, 6 ounces. This airframe would easily carry another 5800 pack, maybe 2 more. What i like is the unbelievable durability of the airframe and how it protects my equipment. I have spun the plane into the ground twice due to a slightly aft CG and once it hit very hard due to interference with my rc transmitter. No damage, not even a loose elevon hinge, nothing. If i were building a larger UAV for gasoline, i would look at 4 stroke ( honda) for fuel efficiency or a gasoline twin, for reduced vibration. My latest 10' span design will use the Hobby King 53cc twin. That span will carry any fuel tank I can put in it. Enjoy.
  • Tyrell John November 11, 2013 at 1:55am

    Been working on the MK802 iv. I see that the Linux perloaded OS is now available. I'm busy trying to do it myself with some help.

     

    http://www.rikomagic.co.uk/forum/viewtopic.php?f=13&t=4696&...

  • Richard Kennedy October 15, 2013 at 6:19pm

    Hi John

    Just read most of you posts here. Great project you have going! I used to make my own foam wings cores for RC planes but as you noted they go from very light to very heavy really fast with epoxy and cloth. What I ended up doing was using 3M77 spray contact cement and believe it or not simple construction paper. What I found was it was fast and cheap and STRONG! Before the paper went on I would carefully cut a small groove for a 1/4" plywood spare that went about %15 of the way in each wing 1/2. I'd glue that in with epoxy. The only downside was the paper would not tolerate water from rain or snow or oil from my 2 stroke nitro fuel. However in my case I didn't care as I was simply trying to teach myself to fly without breaking a balsa wing that took forever to make. So it didn't need it to last forever and if I had a hard landing [ that happened a lot learning! ] it was no big a deal I'd just make another one. It occurred to me you might want to do what I did or similar and not worry about a top notch professional wing at least for the early phase of testing so you can concentrate on the other issues. If you damage the wing during trials its not a huge setback. Anyway good luck!!!!
  • 100KM
    crystal garris October 7, 2013 at 11:54pm
    @ben,
    for out of the box 3 hour electric performance, check out the techpod. I have already done a 2hour 50 minute flight.
  • Ben Weber October 6, 2013 at 4:29pm

    I'm working on a solution for transmitting the PPM signals via cell phone signal without the need for a data connection . I'm hoping its possible and basing my hypothesis the "Audio" input and output on my Turnigy 9x transmitter connected to the Mic/Audio jack on a cell phone.

    I've found this http://www.flytron.com/programmers/56-compufly-usbtoppm-converter.html which converts serial to USB for flying with a computer.

    There are several flight simulators which convert a PPM signal to a serial/auxilary for using a standard RC TX for flying a simulator. I'm hoping someone will have some in depth knowledge of this idea.

  • Thomas Allard October 5, 2013 at 6:22pm

    Ben or Tyrell ?

    Am curious?? do you, or have you, ever flown anything????

  • Tyrell John October 5, 2013 at 2:31am

    A recharging self start solution.

     

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HL1wzOx_JbU

  • Ben Weber September 26, 2013 at 5:24pm

    That's very impressive Tom. I'm forward to your blog post. How long are your flight times?

This reply was deleted.

Activity

Neville Rodrigues liked Neville Rodrigues's profile
Jun 30
Santiago Perez liked Santiago Perez's profile
Jun 21
More…