Should I use PPM encoder or PPM receiver?

Good day.

I usually fly helicopters but I bout a quadcopter, pixhawk, 3dr radios and gps.

I realise the pixhawk uses PPM. I have a 7ch spektrum receiver. I was wondering, for a quadcopter, do I need 8 channels or is 7 channels enough? Because I know that aruducopter for helis needs 8 channels. So can a 7 channel receiver work for quads?

Next question. 

Is is better to use a normal receiver and ppm encoder or a ppm receiver? Bear in mind I already use a spektrum DX8 radio and spektrum has no ppm receivers. Only a company called lemon rx and I dont know if I can trust them.

You need to be a member of diydrones to add comments!

Join diydrones

Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • Can 2 or more spektrum remote receivers be connected to the Pixhawk for a standard diversity solution?

    • Was wondering the same thing.
      • With just a satellite you do not get the protection of the throttle failsafe.  Satellites do not have failsafe capability.

        We have used the LemonRC with PPM and failsafe on the Pixhawk with good success. Hopefully Spectrum may release a similar product with more and more flight controllers requiring PPMSUM inputs.

  • I have a spectrum satellite receiver. But I read somewhere that it's better to have a full receiver vs the satellite. Is that true? Or am I perfectly good using satellite?
    • Nope, the satellite is a receiver, just without the servo pins and such.

      Two satellites would be the most robust so you can have some diversity.

  • As Chris said, just get a Spektrum satellite and plug it into your Pixhawk, then you will have all 8 channels in a clean setup.

    You really only need 5 channels to fly: 4 for the controls and 1 for mode selection. I use 6 with the extra one to control tilt of my camera gimbal.

  • 3D Robotics

    Seven channels is fine for a quadcopter. Although Pixhawk is designed for PPM receivers, it has a special port for the Spektrum satellite connection, so you should be able to use the radio gear you already have. 

This reply was deleted.

Activity

Neville Rodrigues liked Neville Rodrigues's profile
Jun 30
Santiago Perez liked Santiago Perez's profile
Jun 21
More…