Twinstar vs RQ-11

Hi All,

 

I am looking to update my current drone setup to either a Multiplex Twinstar or Nitroplanes RQ-11. The primary purpose of this drone is to take vertical aerial photos for making Digital Terrain Models.

 

I am looking for a plane that can

  • Handle some wind (say up to 15 knots)
  • Be easy to fly manually (I'm no expert pilot)
  • Be hand launched as I won't have access to a runway always
  • Has enough internal space for APM and a Canon P&S style camera, downward pointing
  • Could possibly have FPV gear added in future

I have settled on the above two planes as they are around the same price, can handle enough weight and seem to be widely used by the APM community. I have the option to buy either one of them. However, they are both quite different animals.

 

The RQ-11 has that Military look that is kinda cool, but I am wondering if it is too fast for a less experienced pilot?

 

I like the durability of foam (ie. the twinstar) and am also wondering if the RQ-11 is too delicate with a fibreglass fuselage. I have recently flown a HK FPV168, which has a fibreglass fuse and balsa wing, and it was way to fast for me, leading to nasty crash. That plane weighed a lot more than the RQ-11 though (3kg vs 1.5kg), so maybe they are not comparable - it just scared me off fibreglass.

 

How does the twinstar go in wind?

 

Any thoughts on the two platforms?

 

Regards

James

 

You need to be a member of diydrones to add comments!

Join diydrones

Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • James, the RQ-11 looks awesome but has some nasty characteristics (such as high speeds and tip-stalling)for use as a UAV. As you have said, you really dont want a fiberglass test platform since it it is more brittle and repairs are more difficult.

    The Skywalker is a good option but there are others too. Some of my UAV/FPV airframes include an EZ* and a 40 size electric trainer.

    As it happens I'm also living in Perth and after a Skywalker. BEVRC which is currently out of stock :( has free shipping for orders $200+ so if you're looking to purhase one, I'm up for a group order.

    If you want some more info feel free to PM me.

    Regards,

    Nick

     

     

  • Moderator
    Xen Skywalker EPO is a good aircraft on terms of payload and stable flight.
  • First, I am no expert on this, but i have the rq-11 raven from nitroplanes, and it really looks good, but one tiny crash and it is broken... The wings have a very thin foil covering it and is easily broken... But as you say it looks cool :) But imo if you are not an experienced pilot, do like me and leave it on the desk until your ready for this...

    I would like to recommend the skywalker, I know readymade rc sells it... This is very similar to the rq-11, it is foam, extremely large inside, bigger wingspan than the rq-11 and can fly really slow..

    Good luck anyways :)
This reply was deleted.

Activity

Jose Araujo liked Jose Araujo's profile
Aug 29
spencer harvey liked spencer harvey's profile
Jul 9
More…