Pixhawk Details #2: Multicolor led and connector demo

Due to popular request, this post features a video of the multicolor led in action, and a second video how to single-handedly unplug DF13 connectors.

This tutorial page again summarizes how to unplug and shows an alternative strategy in slow-motion that does not require pulling on the wires. We hope that these videos illustrate well that users do not need to be afraid of higher-density connectors.

We would be very interested in feedback on the multicolor led. There are a few considerations to add:

  • We know the DJI pattern, and believe it is too complex. We would be looking for something simpler
  • It would be beneficial to limit the number of blink patterns and colors to a minimum
  • It will be impossible to map all system states, so the core and important points need to be prioritized and indicated

We are looking for feedback in particular on these aspects:

  • What are the system properties you would like to see visualized (arming status, low battery, gps lock, mode, etc)
  • What do you consider suitable blinking patterns and how many different ones? (e.g. breathe, steady on, fast blink)
  • How should patterns and colors be assigned to things to show? (e.g. one breathe for disarmed, steady on for armed and color for something else? Or yellow disarmed, green armed and pattern for something else?)
  • Any other ideas / considerations?

We will not be able to suit everybody's needs. But we want to hear from the community what matters and see if we can pick up some new good ideas to get this 'right'. We're looking forward to lots of feedback (and opinions).

Views: 7689

Comment by S. Rado on September 3, 2013 at 2:47pm

I think the breathe pattern is perfect for something like disarmed as it is the same indication most notebooks and PCs use nowadays to signal standby mode.

A solid color should indicate normal states like being armed, while blinking patterns (preferably in alarming colors like red) may indicate errors.

Comment by Alex Hills on September 3, 2013 at 3:11pm

my thoughts:

blinking blue- aquiring satellites

blinking red- low battery

color changes from green to yellow to red as battery drains

blinking green- rtl or auto

solid green- stabilize

breathing green- alt hold, loiter

breathing blue- armed, ready to fly

Comment by Josh Potter on September 3, 2013 at 3:35pm

Solid color of some sort to show armed; perhaps orange?  I like the idea of a breathing color for disarmed or acquiring satellites. 

Oh course a fast blink red or yellow for problems.

Comment by Jiro Hattori on September 3, 2013 at 3:38pm

It might good to give two functions on this indicator. One is sanity check for radio, accelerometer, compass calibration and GPS 3D lock. If you could not arm and certain color indication will help what is wrong on sanity check. Another function might be good to indicate flight mode. Actually, I personally like one digit seven segment display, similar to old workstation diagnostic indicator:-)

Comment by Alex Lee on September 3, 2013 at 3:44pm

a 1 digit seven segment display on a 8inch cable with a mini plug so we could have remote status would be greate

 

Comment by Chris Riccio on September 3, 2013 at 4:04pm

My issue with the LED is its position. The reason the NAZA has a loosed LED module that you position on its own is for visibility. Get the vehicle up past eye level and that LED becomes useless. With the NAZA's (not a NAZA/DJI fan at all, btw) you can attach it to a landing gear leg or on the bottom of the fuselage of your fixed wing.

Comment by Alex Hills on September 3, 2013 at 4:09pm

@Chris, the pixhawk has support for external LED modules

Comment by Gary McCray on September 3, 2013 at 5:22pm

The Ultra Bright external LED is going to be a major option for the PixHawk and will provide broad daylight confirmation of flying condition in line of sight operation under the vast majority of circumstances (straight into sun maybe not).

As a result, communications of flight condition need to be very clear and not complicated.

My suggestion is to implement different display feature for different status:

Blinking = Fault or Alarm with specific color indicating specific status.

Breathing indicates good but not ready to fly status (Safety switch not pressed (released), Not armed, Aquiring GPS).

Solid Color On conditions all indicate healthy and flyable: Possibly color = mode Stabilize, Alt Hold, Loiter, Auto, RTL, Waypoint, Etc.

Faults occurring in flight could be solid current (or engaged failsafe indicating) flight color plus brief fault indication blink sequence of appropriate fault color.

KISS is one of my main mantras.

Really like the breathing mode by the way 50% increase in the simple communication capabilities without adding confusion.

Comment by Alex Lee on September 3, 2013 at 8:47pm

don't overlook the fact that colors could be a disadvantage to those that are colorblind. pulsing light would be fine, but a simple 0-9 status indicator or even graphics on it could be quite informative.

Comment by Kelly Schrock on September 3, 2013 at 9:04pm

I like the addition of "breathe". Between slow flash, solid, fast flash and "breathe", plus a few colors, a lot of things could be communicated. 

I see it's "daylight visible", but the LED appears to be on the top of the box. I assume the plan is for this LED to be visible from the ground? I do like the Phantom's LED location, which makes it very easy to see status from 200-300 feet away.

Comment

You need to be a member of DIY Drones to add comments!

Join DIY Drones

© 2019   Created by Chris Anderson.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service