PWM Frequency and compatibility of ESC's

Hi all,

I'm using a Turnigy Trust 55A ESC (well, trying to use) ESC.

http://www.hobbyking.com/hobbyking/store/uh_viewItem.asp?idProduct=12190

Using my O-Scope, I can see the PWM output of the APM2, and it's 490 hertz or so, but the pulse widths are the same as the receiver output which is 49 hertz or so.

The difference is the frequency, the pulse widths are nearly the same throughout the range.

My problem is that if I connect the ESC directly to the receiver, it works fine.  But connected to the APM2, the ESC's just play this one repeating musical note at about 10 hertz.  A very annoying musical composition to say the least, plus it doesn't work!

I can see the output of the APM2, other than the frequency, it's the same as the output of the receiver.

So it looks to me like the APM2 isn't compatible with the Turnigy Trust ESC's. 

Is there a solution to this problem?

Thanks,
Dan Gray

P.S.  this will be my 3rd set of ESC's for this machine.....

Here's my history of ESC's.  First I purchased 50 amp RedBricks from hobby king.  I tested one alone, and was able to get 2.5 LBS of thrust from one motor.  

The moment I connected the 4 ESC's PWM wires together on the APM2, Not a peep came from these RedBrick ESC's, they all completely stopped responding in all respects.  They are DEAD, no beeps, nothing.  I went on the HobbyKing Website, and looked at the reviews, and almost everyone had problems with them.

I was in a hurry, I purchased from a local hobby shop, some 35A Swift SkyRC ESC's, and installed those.  These worked, but they have an AutoZero "feature" that makes them Beep Slowly ALL THE TIME, unless you're actually spinning the motors!  

My solution was to change the firmware 2.7.3 to put out a slightly higher PWM when APM2 wasn't enabled.  This made the beeps only happen when the APM2 was enabled.  This allowed me to use the swift ESC's.  But they only provided 1.7 LBS of thrust, so I wanted to change them.  Also, two of them failed during configuration!  Had to make another trip and buy more from the hobby shop.

So, now there's THREE ESC's that I simply DO NOT LIKE!

Ok, I looked at the Turnigy's, and checked the reviews, they seemed fine.  But now I have this third problem as described above, and I'm really frustrated.  I want to fly my new machine!

Any help would be appreciated.

You need to be a member of diydrones2 to add comments!

Join diydrones2

Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • Are you plugging the ESC's into the APM or into a Power Distribution Board?

    The reason I ask is I have this problem with some OS ESC's in that they will just sit there if I use the PDB but will operate if I them directly into the APM.

This reply was deleted.

Activity

DIY Robocars via Twitter
https://t.co/rLmFr8M2UK
52 minutes ago
Hank Deucker left a comment on PIXHAWK
"Tomorrow, I am thinking about the wording at the moment."
12 hours ago
DIY Drones via Twitter
Welcome to the new DIY Drones design!. You may have noticed that DIY Drones looks a little different today. That's… https://t.co/cg2EmeDGMQ
yesterday
DIY Drones via Twitter
New! Online Training on Drones for Disaster Response https://t.co/brqRuujjY2
Tuesday
DIY Robocars via Twitter
https://t.co/8EMCvYW6oz
Tuesday
DIY Robocars via Twitter
RT @OttawaAVGroup: We are going to try something new this week. We will be having a drop-in style meeting Wednesday @ 7-9pm EST. Pop in and…
Monday
DIY Robocars via Twitter
RT @tawnkramer: Thanks Everyone for another fun virtual race! Amazing Ai racers competing head-to-head, Virtual Makers Fair event. Catch us…
Sunday
DIY Robocars via Twitter
RT @make: Find out the latest from @diyrobocars at 10am PT from @chr1sa of @3DRobotics on Virtually Make Faire! #makerfaire #maketogether #…
Saturday
DIY Robocars via Twitter
RT @Heavy02011: Join us Saturday online: Virtual Race League: @DIYRobocars Race #2 - Parking Lot Nerds https://t.co/aJUu4sdutx #Meetup via…
Saturday
DIY Robocars via Twitter
RT @donkey_car: Yay, we are part of the virtual @makerfaire with @diyrobocars. Come see our race or better yet train a model and race with…
May 21
DIY Robocars via Twitter
RT @chr1sa: The @DIYRobocars Virtual AI Race is going to be part of the virtual @makerfaire on Sat! https://t.co/wnMDAboLID
May 20
DIY Robocars via Twitter
RT @tawnkramer: Please join us next week for our second DIYRobocars online race. We will be using a new Mountain Track course! https://t.co…
May 19
DIY Robocars via Twitter
RT @SmallpixelCar: I realized that the size of the cones in @diyrobocars is known. If we can detect the bounding box, which can be done wit…
May 19
DIY Drones via Twitter
RT @chr1sa: Our next @DIYRobocars autonomous car virtual race is this Saturday. Sign up here to compete or just spectate on @Twitch https:/…
May 19
DIY Drones via Twitter
Definitive Guide to Setup Drone Delivery System https://t.co/7ibwcgF24h
May 19
DIY Robocars via Twitter
RT @DAVGtech: The next @diyrobocars virtual robocar race is this Saturday. One of many interesting issues we are taking a stab at is "how c…
May 18
More…