Moderator

Texas "Anti Drone" Laws Would be Toughest in USA

03ttDrones-articleLarge.jpg?width=300

Interesting legislative activity in the Lone Star State:

A drone, no bigger than a toy airplane, hovered north of the Texas Capitol, floating over the heads of lawmakers who were momentarily distracted from their morning meetings. Several of them gathered beneath it, faces tilted skyward, marveling over a pair of goggles that allowed them to watch live video of the craft’s panoramic bird’s-eye view.

But when the conversation turned to the reason for the demonstration, the tone shifted. Representative Lance Gooden, Republican of Terrell, said he was sponsoring legislation to prevent this futuristic technology — increasingly used by everyone from aviation hobbyists to law enforcement authorities — from capturing “indiscriminate surveillance.”

http://www.nytimes.com/2013/02/03/us/lawmakers-aim-to-limit-drones-and-safeguard-privacy.html?_r=0

http://radio.woai.com/cc-common/mainheadlines3.html?feed=119078&article=10784277

Of particular interest to our community:

“It will be a greater burden on the hobbyists, but I think that’s O.K.,” Mr. Gooden said. “If you’re asking me to choose between my right to privacy and a hobbyist’s right to take pictures from the sky, my privacy comes first.”

and a counterpoint:

“If I’m using it to continuously monitor somebody, I think we could make a law that would forbid such a thing,” Dr. Humphreys said. “But if I’m up there doing some other benign research and happen to capture your picture inadvertently, I don’t think ought to be outlawed.”

And as an administrative note, Chris has created a forum for talking about government drone regulations.

http://diydrones.com/forum/categories/regulation/listForCategory

E-mail me when people leave their comments –

You need to be a member of diydrones to add comments!

Join diydrones

Comments

  • Moderator

    I've started an analysis and write-up of the legislation here:

    http://eastbay-rc.blogspot.com/2013/02/notes-on-proposed-drone-legi...

    My goal is to present a clear set of hobbyist use cases and suggested amendments to protect hobbyist and "light commercial" flying under that regulation.

    It's a work-in-progress, and I'm looking for feedback... please leave comments (either here or on that page) if you think there's something I'm overlooking.

    Notes on proposed Drone Legislation
    Media Certified Drone Hobbyist! Here's some notes I'm putting together on the legislation being proposed in Texas by Rep. Lance Gooden (...
  • Moderator

    Why not take the tack that they are doing nothing somebody with a smartphone wedged in a tree could do for hours.

  • on those links alot of commentators were talking about shooting down the drone, we deserve protection too.

  • Developer

    Drones aren't the problem. Not even by a long shot. If those politicians truly where worried about protecting privacy and “indiscriminate surveillance", they would be going after smart phones and private company surveillance systems pointing cameras out into public space. Today, if there are people nearby then you also have a camera with recording capability nearby. Period.

    Attacking drones is just an easy and sure way for the politicians to get free attention.

  • Developer
    There seems to be a lot of posts about anti-drone laws recently. To me it means that it is obviously a polarizing political issue for many. I.e, half for and half against. Politicians leverage this so they can win on only one topic with a swing of <1%. It's demonstration how democracy is broken. No law will be enacted, only a politician will be elected. That's my guess, but always best to be vigilant.
  • Distributor

    Well, I think that what is proposed is something like to "repeal the law of gravity" ...

  • well im going to basic and as much as I want to contue writing them I cant so starting monday yall be my voice.

  • Ya, I saw a video of this moron saying "you could park a $500 drone over your neighbors house, 24/7 and watch their kid's". I want those batteries!  It's right wing and left wing politicians trying to cash in on the public's anti drone / anti big brother irrational hysteria.  Fueled by a clueless media, that is fueled by a clueless & paranoid population.

    Hopefully reason will prevail in the end.

  • Our small team wrote Rep. Gooden explaining all of these things. He responded via cell phone 15 min later asking is to review the bill and let him know what we don't like. We're working on putting the verbage on paper and sending it to him. After the talk CBS Evening News contacted was for an interview but we forwarded her over to a Byron in Wimberly who runs a fleet of UASs for the search and rescue team of the fir department.
  • Moderator
    The sad part is most people have no idea how long hobbiests have been flying with cameras. This is nothing new. What about the guy this past year who's video helped close that processing plant that turned the local creek red from animal blood? Or the teams who look for lost hikers... Too bad folks only seem to remember hype.
This reply was deleted.