Choosing an airframe

3689387755?profile=original

The entire community runs off the knowledge of others, recommending things for each other, building things for each other, coding things for each other. As I am trying to get some code together for later release it came to me that the maths I'd been using to help an RC Groups thread would be spot on for us. I of course posted it but changing it regularly (thanks to new model planes being released) has meant the file has to be uploaded continually to the thread so here is its own blog post. I actually posted an older one on my first blog but as I've altered it somewhat.

The file is nothing special in itself it just collates information and shows the viability of an airframe mathematically (not physically). The maths evaluates the attributes of an airframe to a few existing experiences (the first 10) on how difficult they were to fly this gives values on the beginner safe planes (wing loading). Again advice dictated to motor recommendations, 90w/lb is a base touted value for flight, 100w/lb is claimed to be perfect for gentle flight maneuvers. Spare mass is the mass you can add without the airframe going over the specified beginner "safe" values. The Additions part is to calculate the size of motor once you start adding stuff thats why a battery is first :)

 

Its certainly not definitive and its certainly not a bible but it should help the first timers or modders looking for a new toy. Just because the maths comes out fine it doesn't mean the plane will. As we have seen some planes are good EasyStar clones with similar specs but space inside them is 40% less thanks to giant walls. Research is your friend I just hope this does a little research for you. Values for the additions are in row 3 so make it bigger and change them if you want (APM is just the basic APM setup - APM + oilpan + MTK).

 

Feel free to post specs for planes that you want or like.

Data required: Name, Wingspan, Wing Area, Flying Mass

Name: Northrup GlobalHawk

Wingspan: 66ft

Wing Area: 169sqft

 

RC Plane Data

E-mail me when people leave their comments –

You need to be a member of diydrones to add comments!

Join diydrones

Comments

  • @T.D. Gonzales

    I suppose I could but this is just something I knocked up to help others its not officially supported or nowt. If I get more planes on board I could upgrade to it. I am also tempted to create a tiny program to do the maths to help out but I'm not sure that would help any more than the spreadsheet and plus others wouldn't get the benefit of the details

    @Mahmood

    No problems

  • I was thinking of making a web based thing like this. Do you think it would be used by the masses to form a comprehensive database?
  • this is awesome thanks for the share
  • what about using google documents? I know we use them a lot in my classes.
  • Imperial and metric on one sheet for conversion reasons.

    No problems Chris as always valuable insight.

  • 3D Robotics
    Perfect--thanks!
  • What about making Imperial units in sheet 2? and SI units in sheet1. Just makes it a bit easier to read..  Don't understand why people still uses imperial though :)
  • 3D Robotics
    Ritchie: a suggestion--add a screenshot excerpt of your spreadsheet to the top of this post, so people can see what you have in mind, Most people won't download and open the spreadsheet just to understand what's in it.
This reply was deleted.